Port City Tavern has let the pirates vacate the ship while letting Santa take over the bar: a pistachio shot comes with its own leg lamp and an Andes mint chocolate to-go. A Miller High Life gets an ugly sweater coozie. A hot toddy with five-spice honey arrives warm. And if you want to get white-girl-drunk, there’s an espresso martini tree.



“Nauti or Nice” has returned to Port City Tavern, trading the nautical horror of Dead Man’s Cove for sailor Santas, tinsel, and a drinks menu from bar manager Kody Hill that spans refreshing and poundable to boozy and warming.
Even more, it remains one of the warmer pop-ups amid Long Beach’s growing love of holiday-inspired experiences. You have the main bar area, designed for social butterflies and pool players. The patio, with warm string lights and two giant TVs—one mimicking a fire and the other playing Christmas movies—offers a cozy outdoor space. And if you want a bit of quiet conversation with your friends, the side room is yours with comfy chairs and couches.



At Port City Tavern, the holidays are good business
“Between Dead Man’s Cove [our Halloween pop-up] and this, we’re finding ourselves amid our best-performing months in terms of sales,” Kody said. “And, now, I feel like we have it down: We understand the decorations and scheduling. We get how we need to tweak the menu. Long Beach is becoming a holiday pop-up city—and honestly, I am here for it.’
This echoes what Port City owner Dylan Davis has noted in the past: the success of Nauti or Nice helped set the stage for Dead Man’s Cove, a trend spreading citywide.





Now, after a month of haunted ships and pirate parties, the crew gets to do it all again in a different set of costumes.
And it’s not just the pop-up itself. The calendar tied to the pop-up is rife with events. Cookies & Cocktails runs every Tuesday in December. There’s a Christmas Parade After Party on Saturday, Dec. 5, at 9PM. There’s an Ugly Sweater Silent Disco on Friday, Dec. 11, at 9PM. And, lastly, a Holiday Paint & Sip (with tickets available here) on Thursday, Dec. 17, from 7PM to 9PM.
The 2026 Nauti or Nice menu
Cocktails



You’re a Mean One ($16): Tequila | Cucumber | Pineapple | Del Santo | Lime



Under the Mistletoe ($17): Del Maguey Vida Mezcal | Guava | Cinnamon | Aperol | Strega | Lemon
Son of a Nutcracker ($16): Old Forester Bourbon | Five Spice Honey | Pear | Lemon
Served warm.



Oh, Snap! ($17): Sagamore Rye Whiskey | Calvados Brandy | Apple Cider Syrup | Bitters



Here for the Ho’s ($18): Vodka | Pomegranate | Falernum | Elderflower | Lime
Includes a souvenir holiday boot mug.



Spice, Spice, Baby ($16): Gin | Spiced Hibiscus | Cranberry | Gentian Amaro | Lemon



Ya Filthy Animal ($17): Bourbon | House Rum Blend | Passionfruit | Macadamia | Grenadine | Vanilla | Lemon



Espresso Martini Tree ($17 single / $68 tree of four): Choice of Espresso or Carajillo
Shots


Photos by Brian Addison.
Fraa-Jeel-Aay! ($15): Pistachio Cream | Branca Menta | White Crème de Cacao
Includes a souvenir leg lamp shot glass.


Photos by Brian Addison.
Cookies for Santa ($12 shot only / $20 with souvenir mug): Vodka | Cookie Butter | RumChata | Coffee Liqueur
The $20 option comes in a souvenir mini Santa mug.


Photos by Brian Addison.
The merchandise lineup includes a 2026 holiday T-shirt ($25), holiday cocktail glasses ($10), and Surfin’ Santa and snowman tiki mugs ($20 each).

Before Long Beach had a citywide holiday bar crawl, it had Miracle.
In 2019, Christy and Jaime Caldwell brought Miracle to The Ordinarie in DTLB. Directly importing the concept from its New York home, Miracle has become the defining holiday pop-up experience in Long Beach. Lines form on day one. The Caldwells take four days to cover nearly every inch of the space with
By the time Baby Gee started making it snow on 4th Street, co-owner Daniel Flores knew exactly where to give credit: “The Ordinarie started it.”
Does this make Long Beach the holiday pop-up capital of SoCal? I am obviously biased because I am always a cheerleader for the city but there’s a real possibility that—given how differently each bar has run with that idea—we could very well be that capital.
Joining Port City Tavern in Zaferia, The Bamboo Club’s Tinsel Club is the region’s definitive space for Christmas-gone-tiki. There’s the aforementioned Baby Gee and, joining them on 4th Street, Dolores and Stache Bar. Wrigley has The Wicked Wolf. Midnight Oil’s new Krampus Kove takes over the main bar while The Lagoon—Midnight Oil’s westerly speakeasy—has its own Trailer Park Christmas in DTLB. And a block up the Promenade from Miracle and across from Midnight Oil, Buen Provecho is giving its Christmas takeover a Latin American point of view…
Long Beach has your holiday pop-up experiences covered.
Port City Tavern is at 4306 E. Anaheim St.


